Popular Articles
If low maintenance is your priority, Onyx shower walls are the better choice. If you want a specific look that only tile can produce, tile is worth the upkeep that comes with it. That is the honest short answer, and it holds up in most of the bathrooms we build.
We install both, and we are an Onyx dealer, so I am not steering anyone toward one material out of convenience. The two perform differently in real use, and the right pick depends on how much cleaning you are willing to do, how unusual your shower opening is, and how much design detail matters to you. Here is how the two actually compare.
What Onyx Shower Walls Actually Are
Onyx is not natural stone, which trips up a lot of homeowners. It is a molded solid surface product made by The Onyx Collection, a manufacturer in Belvue, Kansas, roughly 90 miles west of Kansas City. Every piece is built to order for the specific opening it goes into: walls, base, seat, niches, trim, and lavatory tops.
The walls arrive as large panels rather than individual pieces. They meet in the corners and get sealed with color matched silicone, so a finished Onyx shower has a handful of caulk joints and no grout at all. The material is nonporous straight through, not glazed on the surface, and it feels warmer to the touch than ceramic or porcelain. Being made a couple hours down the highway also means lead times on custom sizes are shorter here than they are for most of the country.
Where Onyx Has the Clear Advantage
There Is No Grout to Maintain
Grout is the weak point of every tile shower. It is porous, it holds soap film, it discolors, and in Kansas City hard water it collects mineral deposits along every line. Sealing helps and does not eliminate it. Eventually grout in a heavily used shower needs cleaning it will not fully respond to, and then it needs regrouting.
An Onyx shower gets wiped down. That is the whole routine. For homeowners who are tired of scrubbing a toothbrush along the shower floor, this one difference usually settles the decision.
It Fits Openings That Tile Has to Work Around
Because every piece is made to order, Onyx handles odd dimensions well. Out of square walls in an older home, a shower that has to fit under a sloped ceiling, an alcove that lands at an unhelpful 58 inches, a tub to shower conversion in a footprint that was never meant to be a shower. The panels get cut to the measurements we take on site. Nothing has to be designed around a tile module.
The Install Is Faster and Less Disruptive
A tile shower is built in stages with waiting between them: waterproofing, setting, curing, grouting, sealing. An Onyx system goes in as prefabricated components. On a bathroom where the shower is the long pole in the schedule, that difference can pull real days out of the timeline, which matters more than people expect when it is the only full bath in the house.
Where Tile Is Still the Better Answer
Design Range Nothing Else Matches
Onyx comes in a broad set of colors and patterns, and the panels read as a clean, continuous surface. What it cannot do is texture and pattern. Handmade zellige with its uneven glaze, a herringbone accent wall, a mosaic shower floor, large format porcelain with dramatic veining, a vertical stack in a specific glaze. If you have a picture in your head of a shower with real material character, tile is how you get there.
This is also where tile and the rest of the bathroom talk to each other. If the floor, the shower, and the vanity area are meant to build one composition, tile gives you the vocabulary. Our article on design flow between spaces covers how to keep those selections working together.
Damage Is Easier to Deal With
Solid surface is durable but not indestructible. Drop something heavy and a panel can chip. You cannot swap out a section of an Onyx wall the way you can pull and reset a cracked tile. Minor chips can be filled, and larger damage means replacing a panel. That is rare in practice, but it is a real difference and homeowners should know it before they choose.
The Comparison in One Place
| Onyx | Tile | |
| Surface | Large molded panels, essentially seamless | Individual pieces with grout joints |
| Cleaning | Wipe down, no grout to scrub or seal | Regular grout cleaning, periodic sealing |
| Design range | Wide color and pattern selection, uniform texture | Nearly unlimited shapes, textures, and patterns |
| Odd openings | Built to your exact measurements | Worked out with layout and cuts |
| Install | Prefabricated components, fewer stages | Multi stage with waterproofing and curing time |
| Repairs | Chips filled, larger damage means a panel | Individual tiles can be replaced |
| Feel | Warmer to the touch | Cool underfoot and against the wall |
The Part Homeowners Underestimate: Waterproofing
Whichever material you pick, the shower fails or lasts based on what is behind it. Tile is not waterproof and grout definitely is not. A tile shower needs a proper waterproofing system installed correctly at the pan, the corners, the curb, and every penetration. When we open up a leaking shower, the tile is usually fine and the waterproofing behind it was never done right.
Onyx reduces the number of places water can find a path, but the base still has to be set properly and the silicone joints still need to be maintained. Recaulking a shower every few years is normal upkeep on either system. Nobody should choose a material expecting it to compensate for a rushed installation.
How I Help Homeowners Decide
When someone is stuck between the two, I ask about their household rather than their inspiration photos. A few patterns come up over and over.
Onyx tends to be the right call when:
- Cleaning time is the complaint you hear most about the current shower.
- The bathroom is a secondary or guest bath where durability matters more than statement design.
- You are converting a tub to a shower and the opening is a nonstandard size.
- Someone in the house is planning to stay in the home long term and wants a low maintenance, easy entry shower.
- The project schedule is tight because it is the only full bath.
Tile tends to be the right call when:
- The shower is the design centerpiece of a primary bath and you want a specific look.
- You want texture, a pattern, an accent wall, or a mosaic floor.
- The bathroom needs to visually tie into tile used elsewhere in the house.
- You are comfortable with grout maintenance as part of owning the room.
There is also a middle path that works well. Some homeowners use Onyx for the base and the wet walls and bring tile in on a single accent area or the bathroom floor. You get most of the maintenance advantage and still land the look.
What We See in Olathe and Overland Park
These two markets keep us busy, and the split between materials tends to follow the age of the house. In Olathe, a lot of the homes we work in were built from the nineties on, with fiberglass units in the secondary baths and a corner tub with a small stall in the primary. Those secondary baths convert to Onyx cleanly, because the goal there is a shower that works and never becomes a chore.
Overland Park runs older on the north end and newer to the south, and we see more tile in primary baths where the homeowner is treating the room as a full redesign. Plenty of Overland Park projects go the other direction, though, especially when a couple is planning to stay in the house and wants the shower to be easy to live with. Our recent projects show both approaches, and our article on must-have features for a modern bathroom covers the details worth building in while the walls are open.
Deciding Before You Order Anything
This decision gets made early because it drives the shower framing, the drain, the niche locations, and the glass. Changing your mind after demo means backing up. We settle the material, the size, and the layout during planning, which is what our design process is built around. If you are still weighing whether the shower replaces a tub entirely, our comparison of walk-in showers versus bathtubs is the right place to start.
See Both Materials Before You Choose
At City Wide Remodelers, we have been building showers for Kansas City area homeowners since 1955, and bathroom remodeling with both Onyx and tile is everyday work for our crews. If you want to compare samples and talk through which one fits your bathroom, schedule a free consultation, call us at (816) 942-1993, or email admin@citywideremodelers.com, and we will walk your space and give you a straight recommendation.
